-Manjurul Haque,
(Senior journalist and international relations analyst)
Judging by the movements of geopolitical tools, it seems that Bangladesh will join the ‘Makkah Military Alliance’ only if it is officially invited.
There has been a lot of debate for the past few days about whether to join the Mecca Alliance or not. While the government’s explanation for joining is valid, the arguments for not joining are even more valid. Although Bangladesh has not yet been invited by the alliance to join as an ‘observer’. However, there is a hint in the government’s talk that Bangladesh will join the Mecca Alliance if invited.
Let’s look inside and out: In short, even a year ago, the Gulf countries, including Saudi Arabia, considered the US military bases to be their ‘own strength’. The Americans were their protectors. That’s why they didn’t increase their military strength despite having trillions of dollars. If that were the case, Saudi Arabia wouldn’t have had to form a 12-nation war coalition to suppress the Houthi rebels.
In this Iran-US war, after suffering successive defeats at the hands of Iran, they have realized how helpless they are against a power like Iran! Iran has not only attacked US military installations, but also destroyed Saudi civilian installations. Since then, Saudi Arabia has jumped into forming a war alliance saying ‘enough is enough’.
On the other hand, Turkey, the largest partner in the alliance, has a long-standing dream of Erdogan – to build a mini version of the Ottoman Empire and become its leader. For that, rather than repairing the economy, they are selling weapons to neighboring countries by promoting slogans such as ‘Caliphate’, ‘Muslim Brotherhood’ and ‘I am on your side’. In particular, their Bayraktar TB-2 drone is the best in the world. They want to make money by selling stealth fighters called Bayraktar TB2, Bayraktar Akinci and Bayraktar Kizillema.
The third partner, Pakistan, is currently using its military to earn money. If they get a large amount, they can send troops to Israel. Such a precedent was set in 1970. The King of Jordan hired Pakistani soldiers to destroy the famous guerrilla unit of the Palestinian Fatah group, ‘Black September’. Pakistani soldiers fought against Palestine, and Zia-ul-Haq was their leader. Now, the only thing Pakistan needs for its collapsed economy is money. Pakistani soldiers are already working in Saudi Arabia. Now, by joining the alliance, they will get a large amount of money from Saudi Arabia. This is their real achievement.
It is said that the ‘Mecca Alliance’ will create rules like NATO. For example, NATO’s Article 5 states that Collective defense is NATO’s most fundamental principle―The North Atlantic Treaty states that an armed attack against one NATO member shall be considered an attack against them all. The Mecca Alliance has also said the same. This has influenced the think tank of Bangladesh. They think that this is one of the ways to protect themselves from the attack of the great power India. If Pakistan-Bangladesh is attacked by India, Mecca will consider it an attack on the rest of the countries of the military alliance and will repel it.
This is precisely where the big flaw lies in the vision of Bangladesh and Pakistani think tanks.
The GDP figures of the three major countries that formed the Mecca Alliance show that; Saudi Arabia’s Nominal GDP is about 1.27 trillion US dollars. Growth this year – about 1.39 trillion dollars. The country’s economy is on the rise.
What is Turkey’s GDP? Turkey’s Nominal GDP Growth: 1.64 trillion US dollars, which is the 16th largest economy in the world, but the growth rate in the last few years is close to 3.4%.
Pakistan’s Nominal GDP is about 452 billion US dollars. Growth: 3.70 percent.
Compared to Pakistan, Bangladesh’s Nominal GDP is about 456 billion. GDP growth is 3.7%.
In this economic situation, Turkey or Pakistan do not have the capacity to give Bangladesh even a single penny. Only Saudi Arabia can give or will give what it can give. If Pakistan gets 5 million, Bangladesh can also get 2.5 million by sending mercenaries. This is the net profit. Nothing Else.
Turkey has entered the field with three objectives here. I have already said one – Erdogan wants to become the caliph of the modern Ottomans. Second: Turkey is also a US-led NATO member, but everyone knows that on the surface Turkey’s relations with the US are bad, but deep down they have a ‘sweet’ relationship. Turkey’s words are clear – we will protect American objectives in this region but we will have to be allowed to do business in the Arabian Sea. America has no problem with that. So they happily allowed the Mecca alliance to be formed.
Does Turkey want to be a bigot in the Arabian Sea to protect Saudi Arabia, Pakistan or Bangladesh? Not at all. Turkey does not have that ability. They want to sell their weapons in this region. They have been testing drones and other weapons extensively in Syria and Iraq for the past one and a half decades and have perfected the weapons. That is why Bayraktar’s drones are now the best in the world. Turkey has already exported drones extensively to all the Gulf countries, Pakistan, Malaysia, Bangladesh, and the Asian countries of the former USSR. Pakistan has its drone manufacturing plant. Now it wants to do the same in Bangladesh. Bangladesh has also allocated land. So whether the ‘Mecca alliance’ ultimately comes to any use or not, Turkey’s arms deals will continue to increase.
Another purpose of Turkey’s grandstanding in this region is to intimidate India. India’s economy is the 3rd largest in the world and the 4th largest in military power. Why try to intimidate it? Because, during the attack on Pakistan last year, India saw that Turkish soldiers also joined the fight at the Nurkhan Airbase in Pakistan. Even the drone of Pakistan that attacked India was operated by Turkish experts. After this, India sold four types of missiles to Greece, Cyprus, Georgia, Armenia and Bulgaria to teach Turkey tricks. It even gave Greece the Russian-made S-400 air defense system. That is, Turkey is now within the range of Indian missiles on all sides.
In such a situation, there is no reason to think that this ‘Mecca Alliance’, like the NATO alliance, will treat the Mecca Alliance as a “Mecca Alliance member shall be considered an attack against them all.” This is because if India attacks Pakistan and Bangladesh, Saudi Arabia will never go against India. Among the many reasons why it will not go, there are two main ones; Almost 90 percent of Saudi’s IT sector is run by Indian experts. India is the second largest labor supplier to Saudi Arabia. Moreover, India is one of the friendly countries of Israel, which is Saudi Arabia itself.
Turkey will not move forward either. Even after Turkish soldiers were killed in Indian attacks during Operation Sindoor in May last year, Turkey did not reveal or counterattack. Instead, it canceled some business deals with India.
Pakistan remains. Even if Pakistan becomes nuclear-armed, let alone Bangladesh, even if Saudi Arabia or Turkey is attacked, it does not have the capacity to counterattack because it does not have the money to buy supplies. It has to take loans from the IMF to pay for the weapons, ammunition and electricity it receives from China in the barter system. What has Pakistan done to remedy the fact that Iran is firing missiles at Saudi Arabia every day, destroying cities, ports and localities? Nothing.
What can these three countries do? Yes, if any of these three countries are attacked by a neighboring country, they can deal with it. But in no way will the other two countries care if Israel attacks Turkey or India attacks Pakistan. They will just be off.
So if Bangladesh thinks that by joining the Mecca alliance, it will be able to talk to India with its eyes closed, that if attacked, the alliance partners will save it, and thus become an important country in the region…. then it must be said that this think tank is living in a fool’s paradise. Several expired war and geopolitical analysts in Bangladesh can be happy thinking, “We are also in a ‘NATO-type’ alliance,” these are worthless thoughts these days.
Of course, it cannot be called ‘valueless’ at all. Sometimes, if the ‘stable beggar’ coalition gets a lot of help, the ‘new beggar’ will also get a little bit of it. Is that less?
Visited 43 times, 1 visit(s) today
https://stapravda.ru/20221228/reyting_samyh_populyarnyh_hostingov_v_rossii_196445.html, рейтинг хостингов России подтверждает, что выбор надежного провайдера важен для бизнеса.