Farce of Justice or Vengeance: Allegations of Bias at ICT, Compared to Zia’s Kangaroo Court

June 1, 2025 • National
Farce of Justice or Vengeance: Allegations of Bias at ICT, Compared to Zia’s Kangaroo Court
Share this News

Staff Reporter

A heated debate and allegations of bias have emerged regarding the trial process at the International Crimes Tribunal (ICT) against ousted Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and Awami League leaders. The tribunal’s Chief Prosecutor, Mohammad Tajul Islam, claimed, “This trial is not about revenge for the past but a pledge for the future.” However, serious questions have been raised about the appointment of lawyers affiliated with Jamaat-e-Islami and its student wing, Islami Chhatra Shibir, on both the prosecution and defense sides, as well as the presence of inexperienced lawyers and the procedural conduct of the trial. Many are comparing this trial to the “kangaroo court” formed during Ziaur Rahman’s era, calling it a farce.

On Sunday, Chief Prosecutor Mohammad Tajul Islam presented a 134-page charge sheet before the three-member bench led by Justice Md. Golam Mortuza Majumdar. The charges accuse Sheikh Hasina of being the “instigator” of crimes against humanity during the mass protests of July-August 2024. Arrest warrants have been issued for Sheikh Hasina and former Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan, while former Inspector General of Police Chowdhury Abdullah Al Mamun is already in custody. The investigation began on October 14 and concluded on May 12, taking six months and 28 days.

However, doubts about the impartiality of the trial process have intensified. It has been learned that some lawyers appointed for the prosecution are linked to Jamaat-e-Islami, while members of Islami Chhatra Shibir are present on the defense side. Notably, Zayed Bin Amjad, a junior lawyer with less than three years of experience from the chamber of Jamaat leader Shishir Munir, has been appointed as a defense lawyer. Even the neutrality of the judges has been questioned, further undermining the tribunal’s credibility.

Chief Prosecutor Tajul Islam claimed on Saturday, “The trial for the July-August killings will be visible by December, and it will be conducted in a way that leaves no room for questioning its integrity.” However, the influence of Jamaat-Shibir and the appointment of inexperienced lawyers have cast doubt on this claim. A social media user wrote, “The prosecution, defense, and judges—all are in Jamaat’s hands. Is this justice or a political revenge drama?”

Lawyer and human rights activist Manzill Murshid said, “International standards must be upheld in the International Crimes Tribunal. But the influence of a specific political party and the appointment of unqualified individuals are raising questions about the judicial process.” He added that international law requires proving “systematic” and “widespread” elements in crimes against humanity, which had sparked controversy in previous trials.

The “kangaroo court” formed during Ziaur Rahman’s regime was infamous as a tool for political vendetta, with allegations of predetermined verdicts. The current tribunal’s Jamaat influence, inexperienced lawyers, and rushed investigation process cast a similar shadow of bias. During a review hearing for Jamaat leader ATM Azharul Islam’s death sentence, his lawyer, Ehshan Siddique, argued, “The previous verdict is questionable because it did not follow international law,” raising further concerns about the current process’s transparency.

A viral video on social media shows the Chief Prosecutor naming former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina as the “instigator” of vandalism and arson at Metro Rail and other key government installations on July 24. This has sparked ridicule among July protest participants on social media. Some July activists admitted in interviews that attacks on national security installations and police were “necessary for the revolution.” Others remarked, “Listening to the charges, it seems Sheikh Hasina was the mastermind behind the July movement.”

After the fall of Sheikh Hasina’s government in the August 5 mass uprising, charges of crimes against humanity were filed against her on August 14. However, Jamaat’s influence and the opaque appointment process in the investigation and trial have compromised the trial’s impartiality. A lawyer, speaking anonymously, said, “When the judiciary is controlled by a political party, it becomes a tool for vengeance rather than justice.”

During the appointment process, the legal advisor himself stated in an interview, “Apart from Jamaat, even BNP lacks competent lawyers who can be appointed to the tribunal.” In that interview, the legal advisor told journalist Khalid Mohiuddin live, “If you can find any qualified lawyer from BNP or any other party, I will appoint them without hesitation.” This statement reveals the transparency of the appointment process.

Public concern over this trial process is growing. Experts warn that a biased trial not only damages the country’s judicial system but also reduces the credibility of Bangladesh’s judiciary in the eyes of the international community. If a fair and impartial trial is not ensured, this tribunal may go down in history as a modern version of Zia’s “kangaroo court.”

Visited 20 times, 1 visit(s) today