Opinion
On 07/08/2025, the BBC published a controversial report titled “Ex-Bangladesh leader authorised deadly crackdown, leaked audio suggests.” Reviewing an 18-second audio clip of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina that was leaked online in March, the BBC concluded in its report that the Prime Minister had ordered the use of lethal weapons to suppress quota reform protesters.
This 18-second phone recording of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina lacks conclusive relevance, and the BBC’s report is riddled with inconsistencies. While Bangladesh’s Evidence Act of 1872 has been amended to allow digital or electronic evidence in court, serious questions remain about the admissibility of this 18-second audio and the credibility of the BBC’s report.
For any evidence to be admissible in court, certain rules, principles, and conditions must be met. Judicial precedent plays a crucial role, referencing past rulings and procedures in similar cases. In cases like Ayesha Siddiqa Minni v State (Case No 47253/2019, GR No 214/2019), the Abrar Fahad Murder (2019), and the Biswajit Murder Case, electronic and digital evidence was presented and accepted—but only after fulfilling specific conditions. The question is: Does this 18-second audio, leaked in March, meet the criteria for admissibility in court?
Under the UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, every citizen has the right to a fair trial and legal counsel. The one-sided trial against Sheikh Hasina that began in June, in her absence, not only violates UN law but also breaches Article 35(3) of Bangladesh’s Constitution, which guarantees the right to self-defense. Before publishing such a report, an international media outlet like the BBC should have exercised greater caution regarding what constitutes “significant evidence” in a biased, questionable, and one-sided court—which it failed to do.
Let’s examine the key inconsistencies in this 18-second audio:
- Chain of Custody: For digital evidence to be admissible, its chain of custody—recording, storage, and dissemination—must be transparent, documented, and reliable. The BBC report does not clarify who leaked the audio, when it was recorded, how it was stored, or how it was released. The BBC claims the audio originated from the National Telecommunications Monitoring Centre (NTMC), a controversial institution, but provides no direct witness as required under Section 60 of the Evidence Act. The lack of a proper chain of custody and direct witness testimony undermines the audio’s admissibility.
- Authenticity: The BBC asserts that the authenticity of this audio—despite its questionable chain of custody—was verified by Bangladesh’s CID and its own forensic audio experts, Aershot. Using technical jargon and discussing sound wave frequencies, the report attempts to mislead readers. However, an 18-second clip, edited and leaked without context, cannot be considered authentic. Presenting a modified version of a phone call as evidence in a sensitive case like this is not only a serious offense but also damages the credibility of Aershot and the BBC.
- Relevance: The 18-second audio allegedly mentions the use of lethal weapons and orders to arrest someone. However, it is clearly an edited fragment of a larger conversation, devoid of context. In criminal law, proving *mens rea* (criminal intent) and *actus reus* (guilty act) is essential—yet the BBC’s report ignores this. The audio does not establish any connection to the quota reform movement or demonstrate criminal intent. A Prime Minister has the authority to order the use of lethal force under appropriate circumstances and legal provisions. The BBC provides no valid argument linking this audio to the alleged crimes.
The leak of this audio three months before the start of a judicial process against a sitting Prime Minister casts doubt on the fairness of the trial. The use of this audio as “significant evidence” in a kangaroo court run by lawyers linked to anti-liberation forces demands greater responsibility from international media. At a time when false narratives about US relations and failed tariff negotiations dominate discussions, the BBC’s unprofessional conduct not only damages its own credibility but also sets a dangerous precedent for accepting fabricated, edited, and politically motivated electronic evidence in Bangladesh’s compromised judiciary.
-Anwar Sadat Jihan
Aerospace Engineering Consultant and Political Activist

https://stapravda.ru/20221228/reyting_samyh_populyarnyh_hostingov_v_rossii_196445.html, рейтинг хостингов России подтверждает, что выбор надежного провайдера важен для бизнеса.