Criticism of Chief Justice: Concerns over granting bail, silence on release of journalists and judges

November 4, 2025 • Law & Order, National, Politics
Criticism of Chief Justice: Concerns over granting bail, silence on release of journalists and judges
Share this News

Staff Correspondent

Journalist and human rights activist David Bergman has sharply criticized Bangladesh’s Chief Justice Syed Refaat Ahmed. In his Facebook post, Bergman alleged that the Chief Justice has sought written explanations from three High Court judges about the high rate of bail grants, but has not expressed any concern about the failure to grant bail in cases of illegal arrests and detentions of journalists, judges, and intellectuals.

Bergman wrote in his post: “This is a revealing statement from the Chief Justice of Bangladesh a few days ago. He expressed concern when bail is granted—but not when bail is routinely denied in court.”

He added, “In the fifteen months since taking office, he has taken no meaningful steps to ensure independent oversight of the judiciary, leaving hundreds—perhaps thousands—of people in prison on criminal charges against whom there is no investigation or evidence. Instead, the courts—especially magistrates and district judges—are acting at the behest of those in power, denying bail, just as they did in politically motivated cases under the previous Awami League government.”

The Chief Justice is now promoting a ‘roadmap to judicial reform’, which he sees as his legacy. But according to Bergman, his legacy will be “the failure of his authority and position to rein in the repressive machinery that is at the heart of Bangladesh’s justice system.”

But Bergman added, “There is still time to do something before his term ends.”

According to a published news report, the Chief Justice has sought a written explanation from three High Court judges regarding the high rate of bail applications.

Bergman’s post has sparked new debate on the issue of judicial independence and human rights.

Visited 128 times, 1 visit(s) today