Opinion
1.
I saw a status of Sergis Alam, one of the coordinators of the quota reform (abolition) and anti-discrimination student movement, two days ago and later on a talk show about his “consultant appointment”. He cited a statistic saying that 4 out of 8 divisions of Bangladesh do not have a single advisor from 20 districts. Out of the remaining 4 departments, only 3 advisors have been appointed from 2 departments. And 21 advisors have been appointed from Chittagong and Dhaka divisions. Sargis expressed anger that he did not have a single advisor from North Bengal. Expressing anger, he said that 13 advisors have been appointed from one department of Dhaka University in the advisory council, while no advisor has been appointed from most of the departments. Basically he explained the law department of Dhaka University. I think his anger is very reasonable. It is a fair claim. We expect such a claim from someone who is a movement for equity or fairness in society or a non-discrimination society. ‘Leaders’ (by the word ‘leader’ we usually mean political leaders) by leading the movement with ordinary students and people for the creation of a non-discrimination society and the abolition of quotas in government jobs. I was wondering whether to use the word ‘leader’. It is a question whether you can call a leader in that sense) Sheikh Hasina brought down the government. People across the country applauded them for toppling an autocratic government as strong political parties like BNP, Jamaat e Islami tried hard for more than a decade but could not succeed in toppling Sheikh Hasina’s government. The Chief Adviser, after taking the oath, repeatedly said that these ‘students’ had put him in power.
2.
To understand the anti-quota movement, you have to go back to 2018. The movement then was more participatory than the 2024 movement. The agitators also gave blood on the streets. They gained a lot of popularity because of their movement based on a logical demand. In the face of strong agitation, the then Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina announced that there would be no quota in the recruitment of government jobs. On October 4, 2018, the Ministry of Public Administration issued a circular to implement the decision of the cabinet by removing the existing quota system for direct recruitment to first and second class posts in government jobs. Relevant: Apart from 30% freedom fighter quota in recruitment to first and second class jobs, district quota, women quota, tribal quota, total quota was 56%. The agitators stopped the agitation after the government abolished the quota completely. Since then the Public Service Commission has been making appointments following this directive.
Later in 2021, the seven children of the freedom fighters filed a writ petition in the High Court challenging the notification of the abolition of quota. Then the High Court accepted the writ and issued a rule asking the government why the quota cancellation notification should not be declared anti-authority. Then for three years there was no discussion about it from the government and from the High Court department.
On June 5, 2024, the High Court declared invalid the circular or notification issued by canceling other quotas including freedom fighters in government jobs. In that case, the High Court Division ordered that all quotas, including the 30 percent freedom fighter quota, will be reinstated. A number of students then took to the streets, and announced a mass movement if the quota was not ‘cancelled’. They argue that the “quota” system creates inequality in the society, hence demand the abolition of quotas. Later, on June 9, the state filed an application seeking to suspend the judgment given by the High Court. Students began to form groups demanding annulment of the High Court verdict. They campaigned in various universities including Dhaka.
On July 2, the Dhaka University campus started a four-point movement. A large gathering of students takes place. Some students blocked the Dhaka-Aricha highway. During the agitation, a six-judge appellate bench led by Chief Justice Obaidul Hasan ordered that the High Court’s verdict on the quota issue be upheld for the time being. Advises Government for leave to appeal. Disobeying the order of the Appellate Division, the students continued their agitation. The government is told that the government will appeal leave to appeal and the verdict will come in favor of the government. But the agitators were not interested to hear them. They again want the quota to be ‘cancelled’ by executive order. The government countered that repealing the executive order would lead to legal complications and would come back through writs. But the agitators are not willing to give concessions.
The full bench of the seven-member Appellate Division headed by Chief Justice Obaidul Hasan gave a unanimous verdict this morning, quashing the judgment of the High Court regarding the restoration of quota on July 21. According to the judgment, 93 percent is based on merit as a quota system; 5 percent for children of freedom fighters, martyred freedom fighters and heroes; 1 percent for minorities and 1 percent for disabled and third gender. However, if the eligible candidates are not found in the prescribed quota, the vacant posts of the respective quota must be filled from the general merit list. In the light of this directive, the Appellate Division directed the executive department of the government to issue a notification immediately. The verdict also said that despite these instructions and orders, the government can cancel, amend or reform the quota if necessary and on overall consideration. On July 22, the then Prime Minister gave his opinion regarding the issuance of the circular as per the instructions of the Appellate Division and on July 23, the government issued the circular reforming the quota system.
Nahid, one of the coordinators of the movement, was found blindfolded on the street. He went missing and was released after 5 days. “In the current situation, one of the coordinators of the anti-discrimination student movement. In a statement titled “Statement of Nahid Islam”, four other coordinators of the anti-discrimination student movement said in a press briefing, “They do not consider the quota reform notification issued without consultation with the agitating students and other stakeholders as the final solution. Notification should be made based on the participation of all parties in the policy making space by creating an environment of proper dialogue. Apart from this, the parliament has not yet passed the law regarding the quota reform. So the quota issue has not yet been finally resolved.â€
Since the current interim government assumed power on August 8, till today, in the last three months, the activists as shadow or pressure groups of the government have come to the field in various activities, but they have not raised any demands regarding the quota reform. However, on October 6, Sargis Alam, one of the coordinators of the anti-discrimination student movement, raised the demand for quota reforms and started recruitment in PSC on his Facebook status. In response, PSC said that PSC will reform as per the government’s wishes. But even after 37 days, the government has not taken any action in this regard. That means the government considers it less important. Since the coordinators have asked for the cancellation of the quota, the notification given by the previous government is also supposed to be canceled (Awami League government is 93% based on merit, the remaining 7% is quota. If you want to cancel the quota, it should also be canceled). It is a kind of fraud with thousands of job seekers participating in the movement. To be honest, the future of ordinary candidates who joined the quota abolition movement is bleak. The government has raised the age of applying for jobs from 30 to 32 a few days ago, but with a provision reducing their chances even further. Earlier a candidate could take the exam as many times as he wanted till he turned 30. As per the current rules one cannot take the exam more than 3 times. It is understood that they have lost more than their gains by throwing out the government. While everyone has an almost equal participation in the movement, some are benefiting greatly, and most are not benefiting at all. This is clearly discrimination.
3.
The purpose of writing the history of the above movement is to try to understand what the agitators actually wanted! Their main demand was to revert the quota system to the 2018 status i.e. completely ‘repeal’. I would like to thank Sergis Alam again for raising the issue of discrimination in hiring consultants in a Facebook status two days ago and later on a television talk show.
The previous quota system in 2018 was the “district quota†in recruitment, which was aimed at increasing representation in government jobs from backward communities. Candidates from 64 districts of Bangladesh took the exam for the job. If there is no district quota, most of the jobs can be obtained from only a few districts if only merit is considered. In that case, the people of other districts will be deprived of government jobs as they cannot survive the competition. Similarly, the rationale for keeping quotas for tribals (officially called ethnic minorities) is similar. As they are variously disadvantaged and backward, equal opportunities are not always available. So there is a rationale for keeping this quota. There are quotas for women all over the world. As women are socially backward and marginalized, they have a life of struggle and may not be able to compete collectively. If there are no quotas then all the recruits in a work environment are male. If this continues, many women will lose interest in taking the job test. In that case, there will be no balance in the workplace, there will be no diversity. Similarly, even if there is no quota in the case of tribals, this diversity will not be preserved. 30% freedom fighter quota is too much. It was logical to bring it down to a tolerable percentage (5% or thereabouts). Completely canceling it was a very wrong decision.
4.
In the country where I live, job applications clearly state that veterans (not just war, but also military), women, indigenous people, visible minorities (immigrants) will be given priority in the competition. This quota thing is called Equity (I can’t find it in Bengali. Justice is also called equity. I will write equity.)! Through it, all kinds of discrimination in the society are removed. Most people don’t understand this thing “Equality is not Equity”. Just because inequality cannot be removed with equality, Equity, Substantive Equity is needed at the ultimate level to remove all obstacles to establish real justice for the oppressed people of the society.
An example can be given to understand this better. Suppose two friends, one boy whose height is 6 feet, another girl whose height is 5 feet, went to watch a game in a field. There is a wall 5 feet 5 inches high in the field from where you get a chance to watch the game. Here both have equal opportunity (Equality) but one can watch the game because he is taller, the other cannot watch the game because he is shorter. What will he do now who is short? He is being deprived despite having equal opportunities. In this case, if a solid tool of one foot height is given under the girl’s feet, standing on it, she can enjoy the game like a boy. This is called equity. Now if the wall in front of them is broken or removed then both of them can watch the game unhindered. This is called substantive equity or substantive fairness. Equity, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI) is taken very seriously to eliminate inequality all over the world. But stay away from EDI in Bangladesh, people have no idea about equity. As a result, if those who will agitate to eliminate inequality do not observe or understand the matter of equity well, then their movement will go in the wrong direction.
The anti-quota movement in Bangladesh did not really come from the “non-discrimination” principle. They seem to have wanted equality, as they wanted the complete abolition of the quota system and recruitment to government jobs on the basis of merit. They have never mentioned district quota – through which the backward one comes – adivasi quota, women quota, freedom fighter quota which is needed in the society, in any demand. From this point of view, this movement stood on an unfairness or to create more discrimination. Sergis Alam also talked about equity in hiring advisors on a TV talk show yesterday. But remember, he has led a movement whose main goal is equality on the basis of “merit” through abolition of all quotas. Never wanted equity. This is extreme self-contradiction and selfishness. According to Sargis Alam, the recruitment of most of the advisers from only two districts and from the law department of Dhaka University is a clear disparity. But in the last three months there has been extreme discrimination in all the recruitments. Sargis Alam did not say anything about it for once. never A few days ago, he announced that at least one person from the family of all the martyrs should be given a job. (There is duplicity in Sargis Alam. When the Chhatra League was banned, Sargis Alam said at one place, “Those who are coming out of the Chhatra League in Dhaka University before the agitation will be freed from this ban. I cannot say about other universities.” The reason for saying this He did BCL politics before becoming coordinator)!
5.
I have written on my Facebook wall several times about substantive equity and diversity. For example, in the six reform commissions, in the appointment of VCs, Provosts of various universities, in the appointment of government lawyers in courts, Hindus and tribals have been severely disadvantaged. This is clear discrimination. The participation of women is very low. Women students are rarely seen in advisory councils and movement leadership. When talking about this discrimination, some people tried to say that how can the government appoint any qualified person from among Hindus or tribals or women. So, in Sargis’ claim of “discrimination in the appointment of advisers”, the government can say that the government has appointed more than half of the advisers from two departments of the country and from the law department of Dhaka University because they did not find anyone “qualified”. This can be called a criticism of Sergis’s argument, as there is a clear discrepancy. However, Sergis will only raise the smoke of discrimination in one case and avoid other contexts, it should not happen. This is his extreme duplicity and selfishness. Again, while the leaders of Dhaka University led the movement from anti-quota movement to overthrowing the government, coordinators of various universities outside Dhaka in Jahangirnagar, Rangpur, Chittagong, Khulna, Sylhet played a lot of role in the movement. This movement would have stopped on the 17th if the private universities had not sprung up. But student advisors and anti-discrimination movement in the government, civic committee, July Smriti Foundation, all places are led by Ken Hasnat, Sargis, Nahid, Asif, Mahfuz, Umama, Hannan, Akhtar, who are all from Dhaka University. Is it discrimination? There is no equity or equality here. Can be considered as an extreme example of discrimination.
Dr. Hasan Mahmud Tipu
Assistant Professor,
Department of Law, Carleton University
Ottawa, Canada
November 14, 2024

https://stapravda.ru/20221228/reyting_samyh_populyarnyh_hostingov_v_rossii_196445.html, рейтинг хостингов России подтверждает, что выбор надежного провайдера важен для бизнеса.