Intense debate over judicial ethics and conflict of interest over Bangladesh Supreme Court ruling

June 28, 2026 • Law & Order
Intense debate over judicial ethics and conflict of interest over Bangladesh Supreme Court ruling
Share this News

❐ Staff Reporter


The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh recently delivered a judgment that has sparked intense debate in legal and academic circles. The judgment raises serious questions about judicial impartiality, conflict of interest, and the constitutional validity of the highest court.

Civil Appeal No. 78/2024 concerns a high-value property located at 40/5 North Avenue, Gulshan Model Town, Dhaka, which was allotted by RAJUK to the late Justice A.F.M. Abdur Rahman Chowdhury. After his death, his heirs — including the current Chief Justice Zubair Rahman Chowdhury — challenged the validity of the conversion fee imposed by RAJUK, which was up to a maximum of Tk 50 lakh per katha, for redeveloping the property for commercial purposes.

In view of Writ Petition No. 9911 filed in 2016, the High Court Division declared the fee illegal on December 11, 2017 and ordered its withdrawal. When RAJUK appealed, the Appellate Division quashed the High Court’s judgment on February 19, 2023 without granting leave, which was later admitted to be unconstitutional. A review petition was then filed, which was granted on October 24, 2024. In its final judgment on November 6, 2025, the Appellate Division restored the High Court’s decision and declared the imposition of the conversion fee illegal. The court fixed the fee at Tk 2.2 million only for that specific property and directed that the judgment would not be applicable as a precedent in the future.

The timeline of the case has drawn particular attention. Justice Zubair Rahman Chowdhury was promoted to the Appellate Division on August 12, 2024. Within two months, his family’s review petition was granted on October 24, and the final verdict on November 6 was the beneficiary. He then assumed office as Chief Justice in December 2025. While there is no clear record of his direct participation in the final bench, legal experts say the proximity of the promotion and a favorable outcome creates “visible apprehensions of bias” — considered sufficient to undermine judicial legitimacy globally.

The most controversial aspect of the ruling is the court’s instruction that the ruling will apply only to the property in question and cannot be used as a precedent in the future. Such a limitation is highly unusual in a common law system founded on the doctrine of starre decisis. Supreme Court rulings are generally binding on lower courts — legal experts say limiting the precedential value of a ruling that affects the interests of a judge’s own family raises serious questions about “selective judgment” and institutional transparency.

The debate has taken on added significance in a global context. In the United States, a 2024 Senate Judiciary Committee report accused Supreme Court justices of failing to refrain from engaging in conflicts of interest cases and of failing to disclose gifts, calling for an “ethical crisis.” The United Kingdom’s 2023 Judicial Conduct Guidelines explicitly state that judges must avoid not only actual bias but also the reasonable apprehension of bias, and must manage personal relationships in a way that does not undermine public trust.

According to the Third Schedule to the Constitution of Bangladesh, judges — including the Chief Justice — take an oath to perform their duties “without fear or favour, attachment or malice.” Legal scholars believe that this oath embodies the fundamental principle of complete impartiality. When a judicial decision directly affects family interests, the question is not only one of legal validity, but also whether the spirit of the oath has been upheld.

The Gulshan Property Case verdict has become a focal point for testing the boundaries between judicial authority and personal interests. While no formal misconduct decision was made, the combination of family benefits, procedural timelines, and precedent limitations raises legitimate questions about institutional integrity. International experience shows that the mere notion of a conflict of interest can have far-reaching consequences — the legitimacy of the courts depends on public trust, and that trust is weakened when judicial decisions appear to be linked to personal or family interests.

Visited 38 times, 1 visit(s) today