Reuters report: How ‘Vergintina’ reached the semi-finals amid controversy, football fans’ distrust

July 14, 2026 • Sports
Reuters report: How ‘Vergintina’ reached the semi-finals amid controversy, football fans’ distrust
Share this News

Defending world champions Argentina are set to face England in the semi-finals of the World Cup. However, the biggest discussion now is the off-field controversy rather than the on-field performance. The opposing teams have alleged that Argentina has reached the semi-finals thanks to a series of controversial refereeing and the use of video assistant referee (VAR) technology. Football fans on social media have even given the Albiceleste a new name – ‘VARgentina’.

Recently, FIFA’s new refereeing protocol has added fuel to the fire of this debate, creating extreme distrust among football fans about the impartiality of matches.

Quarter-final against Switzerland and Embolo’s red card

The controversy reached its peak on Saturday during Argentina’s quarter-final match against Switzerland at Kansas City Stadium, when Swiss forward Brill Embolo was sent off after receiving a second yellow card (for diving or simulation). Referee Joao Pinheiro showed him a red card after a VAR review.

Swiss coach Murat Yakin called FIFA’s VAR decision “unacceptable,” sparking a social media frenzy.

New protocols and experts’ concerns

New rules or protocols for VAR interventions, which have not been widely tested before, have been introduced for the current 2026-27 season and the World Cup. Former FIFA referee and rules analyst for British broadcaster ITV Christina Uncle has strongly criticized the new protocol.

In an interview with Reuters, Christina said:

“I don’t think this protocol should have been implemented in the first place. It’s too broad. My objection is that we’re not just changing who gets a card, we’re changing the underlying decision. A free-kick should have been awarded to one team, and from there the decision is reversed and given to the other team. In other words, we’re changing the basis of the decision.”

According to him, the main function of VAR was to help the referee, not to ‘re-referee’ the match. But this protocol is pushing referees towards that ‘re-refereeing’. The fans’ anger has been further inflamed by the fact that this new rule favors the Argentine team. Uncle added, ‘The expansion of this protocol without testing is like a gunpowder pile. I’m just waiting for the final explosion.’

Continuation of the debate that began in the group stage

The allegations of bias surrounding Argentina are not limited to one match. The controversy began to spread from the group stage:

  • Match against Algeria: Argentina captain Lionel Messi was not shown a red card after he kicked Algeria captain Aissa Mandi in the leg in the first half. Messi scored a hat-trick later in the match. Algeria filed an official complaint after the match for poor refereeing.

  • Match against Austria: Questionable refereeing also occurred in the group stage match against Austria. McAllister threw an Austrian player in the buildup before Lionel Messi scored Argentina’s first goal. Although the goal should have been disallowed according to the rules, VAR did not intervene in this case. Austria’s complaint was not taken into account, and the team also made a formal complaint after the match.
  • Last 16 match against Egypt: Egypt scored a goal in the 62nd minute of the match, but it was disallowed after a VAR check. The reason given was a foul in the build-up to the goal. Egypt’s penalty appeal was rejected late in the match and Argentina scored the winning goal in the 92nd minute. The Egyptian Football Association alleged that several refereeing decisions had determined the outcome of the match. FIFA’s refereeing chief Pierluigi Collina, however, dismissed claims of any bias in the match against Egypt.

Although Christina Ankel believes that there were no major refereeing errors in the matches against Algeria or Egypt, she believes that some of the decisions off the field have raised serious questions about FIFA’s impartiality in the minds of fans.

Extreme distrust of fans

Some recent FIFA decisions have further fueled the distrust among fans, such as the one-match ban lifted on US striker Folarin Balogun at the last minute, while England defender Jarrell Kwansa was given a two-match ban.

Christina Ankel, president of USL Women’s League team Tampa Bay Sun FC, said of the fans’ anger:

“I think the trust of the fans has completely collapsed. I’ve covered many big tournaments as a referee and analyst, but I’ve never seen so much anger and discussion about referees on social media or off the field.”

The controversy over refereeing and the lack of confidence from fans ahead of the crucial semi-final against England has put enormous pressure on FIFA and match officials.

Visited 27 times, 1 visit(s) today