Review of the Constitution Reform Recommendations by the Commission Formed by Mr. Yunus

January 17, 2025 • Opinion
Review of the Constitution Reform Recommendations by the Commission Formed by Mr. Yunus
Share this News

Opinion

The Commission formed by Mr. Yunus regarding the constitutional reform of Bangladesh has submitted recommendations for constitutional reform. In brief, I would like to say that this is tantamount to treason.

Review:

The summary of the recommendations of the Constitutional Reform Commission states that the Constitutional Reform Commission is considering seven main issues with the aim of establishing an effective democracy, ensuring fundamental human rights and accountability. They are: (1) The proposal of “equality, human dignity, social justice, pluralism and democracy” as the basic principles of the constitution and state, reflecting the great ideals of the 1971 war of independence and the popular aspirations of the 2024 popular uprising.

The above-mentioned proposal number one is tantamount to treason. Considering the great freedom struggle of 1971 and the people’s uprising of 2024 from the same perspective, the proposal to change the basic principles of the constitution is illegal and indecent, that is, it is an interference in the basic principles of the constitution formulated in a completely systematic manner in a state formed after achieving success through a long struggle and a nine-month bloody war, and it is extreme treason.

Because the constitution of 1971 was formulated by the Constituent Assembly elected by the people. Before the independence of 1971, there was a mass uprising in 1969 through a mass movement in the light of the people’s aspirations, then parliamentary elections were held in 1970, in which the Bangladesh Awami League achieved an absolute majority, and the constitution of the independent state was formulated through the elected people’s representatives in the general election of 1970. There is no opportunity to consider the liberation war and the mass uprising in the same criteria. Moreover, for the sake of argument, if we consider it appropriate to change the basic principles of the constitution by reflecting the aspirations of the people in conjunction with the 2024 mass uprising, then like the 1970 election after the 1969 mass uprising, an election should be held this time too and the 2024 mass uprising leaders should get an absolute majority in parliament by the people’s vote. Otherwise, it will be immoral interference in an independent sovereign state, which should be considered a crime of treason.

Now, let me say something about the commission’s scholarly expression in the full recommendation. The commission’s proposal has been made in Bengali, while reading it, I felt that the drafters are very weak and immature in Bengali language. Using the word ‘one’ before the word ‘effective democracy’ is an immaturity of Bengali language knowledge. The second paragraph of the seven main points states, “Establishing Institutional Balance of power ”. This is not a meaningful sentence. Perhaps it was meant to say, “Establishing Balance of Instituitonal Power”. A word has been used in the seventh paragraph,  “Strong competence” (বলবৎযোগ‍্যতা). Adding ‘ta’ to the word ‘বলবৎযোগ‍্য’ is against the Bengali language. Perhaps, based on what it was trying to convey, it would have been appropriate to use the word  “Enforceable” (‘বলবত্তা’) there.

However, without going into the arguments of spelling mistakes, grammatical errors, let us discuss the substance of the recommendation. The Commission recommends replacing the existing preamble to the Constitution with the following commentary. The first two paragraphs of the preamble state, “We, the people of Bangladesh, who have achieved independence through a people’s war in the course of a historical struggle for the liberation of the people of this land and have built a united resistance against the dictatorial and fascist rule to establish democracy;

We, remembering the sacrifice of all the martyrs with utmost respect, pledge that, in order to establish in the state and society the ideals of equality, human dignity and social justice that united the people of Bangladesh in the war of independence in 1971 and the ideals of democracy and non-discrimination that united them against the fascist rule in 2024; “ ….

The intention to divide Bangladesh has been expressed through the aforementioned proposal. Because in 1971, we the people of East Pakistan fought against the West Pakistanis to achieve independence and we won the war of East Pakistan and established the independent sovereign state of Bangladesh, West Pakistan is on the map of the world as a separate state called Pakistan. Then, in 2024, the said proposal will be replaced in the constitution stating that those against whom the people fought and won in 1971, will have to recognize or create the existence of another state on the map of the world.

Under the heading ‘Civil Democracy’, Clause-1 states, “The Commission recommends that the words ‘Civil Democracy’ and ‘People’s Democracy’ be used in all applicable cases of the Constitution instead of the words ‘Republic’ and ‘People’s Republic of Bangladesh’.”

Through the above proposal, the 6-point Emancipation Proclamation of the People of Bangladesh in 1966, the 11-point Student Union, the 1969 mass uprising, the 1970 elections, and the achievements of the great Liberation War of 1971 have been insulted, which is unfair, unpopular, indecent and treasonous.

Under the heading ‘Legislature’, it is stated, 1. The Commission proposes a bicameral legislature; a lower house, the National Assembly, and an upper house (the ‘Senate’).

Lower House 1. The lower house will be formed by directly elected members by majority vote. The lower house will be formed with 400 (four hundred) seats. 300 (three hundred) members will be directly elected from single regional constituencies. Another 100 women members will be elected from 100 (one hundred) constituencies designated in this regard from all districts across the country.

According to the above proposal, women candidates will have to be elected in each seat as against 100 seats in the constituency of 300 seats, consisting of three times the voters of the area of ​​each candidate elected. This is discrimination. With the anti-discrimination proposal in the Constitution, it is undesirable to propose such discrimination for women in the same Constitution.

Clause-5 states, “A member of Parliament shall not hold more than one of the following positions at the same time; (a) Prime Minister (b) Leader of Parliament (c) Head of a political party.”

The above proposal will lose momentum in the parliamentary system of government, the Commission has failed to realize the existence of the parliamentary system. Because in a parliamentary system of government, the head of the government, i.e. the Prime Minister, will be accountable to the Parliament, so it is appropriate for the Prime Minister to be the Leader of Parliament. The one who is elected as the Leader of Parliament according to the rules, will be the Prime Minister or he will elect the Prime Minister. If a political party believes that they will win a majority in Parliament and nominate someone else as the Prime Minister, based on the party’s ideological considerations, the Leader of Parliament himself may do so, but it would not be reasonable or meaningful to make it a constitutional obligation.

Clause 1 of the Upper House states that the Upper House shall consist of a total of 105 (one hundred and five) members; out of which 100 members shall be determined in proportion to the total number of votes cast in the National Assembly elections. Political parties may nominate a maximum of 100 (one hundred) candidates for the nomination of the Upper House on the basis of proportional representation (PR) system. Out of these 100 (one hundred) candidates, at least 5 shall represent socially and economically backward communities in the manner prescribed by law. To fill the remaining 5 seats, the President shall nominate candidates from among the citizens (who are not members of any House and political party).

It is unclear in the above proposal that “at least 5 out of 100 (one hundred) candidates shall represent socially and economically backward communities” by distributing 100 members among the political parties in proportion to the total number of votes, or how these five will be selected from the backward communities of the society, as mentioned in the above proposal.

If the entire proposal is analyzed in detail, many more errors are noticeable, but the major errors have been highlighted in broad strokes.

I am a lawyer, yet I have no hesitation in admitting that the scope of my knowledge is very limited. If I get the slightest acceptance from the lawyers, political scientists, constitutional experts and conscientious people of the country and abroad who will read my comments and observations, I will be grateful. My sincere love to those who have read it with patience.

Puran Das,
January 16, 2025.

 

Visited 24 times, 1 visit(s) today