❐ BD Digest Desk
The resignation of international criminal law expert Toby Cadman cannot be interpreted as a simple administrative decision or a personal disagreement. It is effectively an international indictment of the ongoing judicial process in Bangladesh, which simultaneously calls into question the three pillars of the legal framework, the moral standing, and the diplomatic future.
When an international jurist with a long history of working on genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity cases publicly says that he feels “embarrassed” by being involved in a tribunal’s proceedings, it is no longer a personal sentiment; it becomes an admission of a systemic failure.
The word Cadman uses—“unilateral”—is a very serious one in the terminology of international criminal law. It is not a political slogan or a loose word of the media. Unilateral justice in international law means the absence of the fundamental principles of justice. Justice is not just a matter of the final verdict; justice is a complete process, in which the formulation of the charges, the taking of testimony, the examination of witnesses, the opportunity to defend oneself, and the independent decision of the judge—all are equally important. If any one stage of this process is structurally unbalanced, then the entire judicial system is called into question.
International human rights law is not ambiguous on this point. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights clearly states that all persons are equal before courts and tribunals and that everyone is entitled to a fair and public trial by a competent, independent and impartial tribunal. The Covenant also provides for the right to defend oneself, the right to legal assistance, to present evidence in one’s own behalf and to be given equal opportunity with the accused.
Bangladesh is a signatory to this agreement. As a result, these principles are not theoretical ideals or moral advice; they are international legal obligations imposed on Bangladesh.
Directly related to this obligation is the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. This statute clearly states that a person is to be presumed innocent until proven guilty. The statute recognizes as fundamental the full right of the accused to a defense, the opportunity to present evidence and testimony in his or her own behalf, free access to a lawyer, and equality before the law with the accused.
At the same time, judges are charged with the responsibility to ensure that trials are fair, impartial, and free from political influence. If any of these principles are violated, the trial is considered invalid by international standards, even if it is conducted under the country’s domestic law.
In light of this legal framework, Toby Cadman’s resignation is particularly significant. He is not just a consultant; he is an insider in the international criminal justice system who knows at what point a tribunal begins to lose its legitimacy. International experts usually try to reform from within until the last moment. When that effort fails and they publicly step down, it signals that the problem is no longer temporary or personal; the problem is deeply structural.
The timing of this resignation is also particularly significant. The withdrawal of an international observer and partner at a time when the tribunal is on the verge of a crucial decision in the post-July Revolution crimes against humanity case naturally raises serious questions. The question arises—is the direction of the verdict predetermined? Has the trial become a mere formality? Are international standards being used merely as a veneer of external legitimacy?
History shows that jurisdictions that are confident in their own fairness do not let international observers leave; rather, they use their presence as a force for their own legitimacy.
A review of the history of international criminal tribunals makes one thing clear—legitimacy always comes from the process, not the outcome. Whether it’s the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, the Rwandan Tribunal, or the International Criminal Court—international criticism has all begun when it seemed that the trial was losing political balance.
But the difference is that, despite criticism, the doors to defence rights, judicial independence and international monitoring have never been completely closed in those tribunals. Rather, criticism has been seen as part of procedural reform. In the case of Bangladesh, Cadman’s resignation suggests that those doors are gradually closing, and the scope for internal reform is rapidly diminishing.
Another important concept comes to the fore here—the international chain of credibility. International legal experts, human rights organizations, UN-based mechanisms, special rapporteurs, and diplomatic missions typically rely on each other’s observations and assessments to take positions. When a recognized international criminal law expert publicly states that a tribunal is biased, it can be cited in future human rights reports, UN briefings, and even documents of bilateral diplomatic discussions. In other words, the impact of this resignation may not be immediate, but it is structural and long-lasting.
This raises a fundamental question: what is the purpose of justice? International criminal justice is not designed for retribution. Its primary purpose is to uncover the truth, establish justice, social reconciliation, and prevent future crimes. The philosophy of both the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Rome Statute is based on this idea. But when the judicial process becomes overly tied to a particular political moment, it risks becoming a retributive justice. Cadman’s resignation reinforces the fear that the current tribunal may be used more to establish political narratives than to prosecute crimes.
In this context, the moral and legal responsibility of the interim government becomes even deeper. A figure like Cadman was added to ensure the international acceptance of the tribunal. He was the government’s international shield and symbol of credibility. Today, that shield has collapsed. If the government does not conduct a transparent investigation into the reasons for this resignation or tries to cover up the matter, then a clear message will be sent to the international community – the problem is not with any one person, but with the structure of the entire judicial system.
The consequences of ignoring this signal will not be limited to domestic politics. International human rights reports, diplomatic pressure, conditionality in development aid, and long-term erosion of international credibility are all possible scenarios. History has shown that once a state’s judicial system is internationally questioned, it is extremely difficult to restore that trust.
The true identity of a state is not revealed in its elections or political rhetoric; it is revealed in its judiciary. If justice becomes a tool of revenge and if the courts become a tool for political ends, that state can no longer claim the moral high ground. Toby Cadman’s resignation has made that moral rift clearly visible. This is a clear international warning signal for Bangladesh—one that, if not heeded in time, could cost it in the court of history for years to come. The court of history is silent, but its verdict is harsh, and that verdict is often unforgiving.

https://stapravda.ru/20221228/reyting_samyh_populyarnyh_hostingov_v_rossii_196445.html, рейтинг хостингов России подтверждает, что выбор надежного провайдера важен для бизнеса.