Human Rights Violations in Joint Initiative by Human Rights Watch and Bangladesh’s Law Ministry

October 13, 2025 • Human Rights, Law & Order, National
Human Rights Violations in Joint Initiative by Human Rights Watch and Bangladesh’s Law Ministry
Share this News
Golam Hossain

Fourteen months and two days after the Bangladesh Army forcibly deported Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina to India on August 5 last year, two formal charges were filed against her at the International Crimes Tribunal on October 8 for alleged disappearance, secret detention and torture. In one of them, 17 people, including Sheikh Hasina, have been accused, and in the other, 13 people, including Sheikh Hasina. The court issued arrest warrants against the accused in both cases. Out of a total of 30 accused in the two cases, 25 retired and serving army officers have been named, out of which 13 officers are currently serving.

A day before the filing of the above complaint, i.e. on October 6, the Law Ministry issued a notification adding a new section to the International Crimes (Tribunal) Act, 1973.

The added clause states, “If a formal charge is filed against someone at the International Crimes Tribunal for crimes against humanity committed during the July Uprising, he will no longer be able to participate in the national parliament and local government elections. He will not even be able to hold any government job.”

Therefore, the 13 serving army officers mentioned in the complaint will be relieved of their duties from the afternoon of October 8, 2025. What does that indicate?

If a complaint is filed against someone in a tribunal, he will be found guilty and punished. However, if at the end of the trial it is proven that the person against whom the complaint was filed is innocent, and the prosecution has failed to prove the complaint beyond reasonable doubt, then the punishment given immediately after the complaint is filed under the newly added section will certainly be unreasonable and contrary to human rights.

The ‘presumption of innocence’ is included as a fundamental human right under Article 11(1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). This principle is enshrined as a core principle of international humanitarian law (IHL).

When and why should you use the ‘presumption of innocence’?

According to legal principles, every person accused of any crime shall be presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the charge cannot be proven beyond reasonable doubt in court, the accused will be acquitted. Therefore, in order to convict or punish a person accused of any crime, the state must present evidence in support of the charge to convince the court beyond reasonable doubt that the crime was committed by the accused.

The accused shall be presumed innocent until the court is convinced beyond reasonable doubt that the offence was committed by the accused on the basis of the evidence presented by the prosecution.

Here we can say that the Ministry of Law issued a notification amending the ICT Act a day before the filing of the complaint with the intention of dismissing the 13 army officers working in the two mentioned cases. This is a complete violation of humanity.

Now, why is there talk of human rights violations in co-production?

See, immediately after the International Criminal Tribunal issued arrest warrants against Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and her government’s Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal, including army officers, Meenakshi Ganguly, deputy Asia director of the New York-based human rights organization Human Rights Watch, expressed satisfaction and titled an article published on their website – ‘Bangladesh takes a step forward on the path to justice’.

This would have been correct if the Law Ministry had not issued a controversial notification a day before the complaint was filed. However, since the Law Ministry issued a notification to ensure that the accused is punished immediately after the complaint is filed, before the trial begins, it cannot be said to be a step forward in the path of justice, but rather a step back of two hundred and fifty years. Now, such a logical argument cannot escape the attention of a human rights organization.

Therefore, the statement by the New York-based human rights organization Human Rights Watch immediately after the filing of the complaint and the issuance of the arrest warrant, and the law enacted by the Bangladeshi Ministry of Law immediately after the filing of the complaint, that is, before the start of the trial, clearly indicate a link between the human rights violations that occurred.

Golam Hossain is
a lawyer and political activist.
Visited 13 times, 1 visit(s) today