In the Current Crisis, President’s Reference to Appellate Division Should Be Recalled for Forming Interim Government

November 2, 2025 • Opinion
In the Current Crisis, President’s Reference to Appellate Division Should Be Recalled for Forming Interim Government
Share this News

Opinion

Bangladesh is currently in an extremely delicate situation. Political instability, misrule, violation of the constitution in the name of the July Charter, misuse of law, violation of human rights, extreme deterioration of peace and order, trampling on the fundamental rights of the people, state-sponsored mob violence and injustice, recession in business and commerce, closure of industrial establishments one after another, increase in unemployment, extreme dissatisfaction with people’s lives, allegations from the large political party BNP that the President and Chief Advisor of the National Consensus Commission, as well as the BNP, has betrayed the nation and the political party BNP. In view of the kind of instability prevailing in the existing reality of the country, it has become extremely urgent to recall the reference to Article 106 of the Constitution and the alleged opinion sent to the Supreme Court of Bangladesh by the Honorable President and abolish the current interim government.

Now the question is, who or by whom will the Appellate Division’s opinion be recalled in light of the reference and its context?

See, recall is a language of our law courts. If an order made by a court is found to be wrong, defective or unnecessary after a period of time, then any of the parties can apply for recall of the order by showing reasonable grounds. Again, the court can also recall an order on its own initiative. This means withdrawing the order on the grounds that it was made inadvertently or unnecessary. From my experience, I have applied for recall of orders in more than one case and the court, after hearing the case, recalled the order on reasonable grounds.

In this case, either the President or the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court can withdraw the reference and opinion. If the President withdraws the reference he sent, then his argument will be that the Prime Minister’s resignation letter is not with the President. On the other hand, the Appellate Division can withdraw their opinion on the grounds that the President’s reference was not raised and heard in the Appellate Division as per Article 106 of the Constitution. Moreover, there is also ambiguity in the Appellate Division regarding the Prime Minister’s resignation. In fact, this should have been done the day after the President’s interview with Matiur Rahman Chowdhury was published in the Daily Manabzamin on October 26 last year.

On October 26, 2024, the editor of the Daily Manabzamin, Matiur Rahman Chowdhury, published a report of his conversation with the President. In it, he wrote, “Army Chief General Waqar-uz-Zaman had informed the media about the resignation of the former Prime Minister. The question has arisen, if the Prime Minister has resigned, where did it go? No one has an answer to this question. I have been searching for three weeks. I have also searched the Cabinet Department. Where the resignation letters of the President, Prime Minister and ministers are supposed to be. They are nowhere. Finally, I met President Shahabuddin at Bangabhaban. He greeted me with great sincerity. I asked, do you have the resignation letter of the former Prime Minister? The President said, I have heard that he has resigned. But I do not have any documentary evidence. Despite many attempts, I have failed to collect it.”

See, since the Honorable President does not have documentary evidence of the resignation letter of the Honorable Prime Minister, he can withdraw the reference he sent on the grounds that it was inadvertent. If the Honorable President does not want to do this, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court can raise Article 106 of the Constitution before the nation and withdraw the opinion. Article 106 of the Constitution states, “If at any time it appears to the President that any question of law has been raised or is likely to be raised, which is of such a nature and of such public importance that it is necessary to take the opinion of the Supreme Court on it, then he may refer the question for consideration to the Appellate Division and that Division, after holding such hearing as it may deem fit, may communicate its opinion on the question to the President.”

Look, the clear wording of the given article of the Constitution is that after a proper hearing, the President can express his opinion on the question. It is clear to the Appellate Division that a proper hearing of the President’s question sent to the Appellate Division after August 5 was not held, the Appellate Division did not sit in session from August 5 to the swearing-in ceremony of the interim government on August 8, and the Appellate Division does not have any record of any hearing being held in person or virtually.

Now the question is, if that opinion or reference is withdrawn, what will happen next? Will there be a constitutional crisis in the country?

My opinion is that there will be no constitutional crisis at all. Rather, an opportunity will be created to resolve the crisis. If the Appellate Division withdraws its opinion, His Excellency the President will send the question to the Appellate Division for an opinion to resolve the crisis again, the Appellate Division will arrange for a hearing following the instructions given in the article of the Constitution and will give its own opinion after the hearing.

If the President withdraws the Presidential Reference, the President will either ask the Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina to discharge her duties or request her to resign in accordance with the appropriate procedure. If none of these things are done, in the near future, the current Army Chief and all the courts where Sheikh Hasina is being tried will face charges of violating the law. Because the Army Chief General Waqar-uz-Zaman had announced the Prime Minister’s resignation in front of the media, but in reality the Prime Minister did not resign.

How will the judges of the courts where trials are being conducted in the name of Honorable Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina be in danger?

Look, no criminal case can be filed against the Prime Minister of the country while he is in office. No trial can be conducted against him. Since the Honorable Prime Minister did not resign, immediately after the news was published in the Daily Manabzamin on October 26th of last year, quoting the Honorable President, all the courts and police stations should have declared the cases against Sheikh Hasina to be abolished.

I would like to mention here that I have come across the documents of a murder case registered against Sheikh Hasina at Paltan Police Station in Dhaka. A businessman has been made an accused along with Sheikh Hasina in the said case. He sent me 38 pages of the case documents. I was shocked after reviewing the documents, the officer-in-charge of Paltan Police Station has done a completely illegal act.

The murder case was filed as a C. R. case in the Dhaka Metropolitan Magistrate Court. The court directed the officer-in-charge of Paltan Police Station to investigate whether there is any case in the name of the victim of the case, i.e. the deceased, and submit a report within three days. The officer-in-charge of Paltan Police Station filed an FIR in the case based on that order, although the court did not ask him to file an FIR in that order. Tughlaq incident.

These records will remain. Today, there may be no rule of law, but if the rule of law returns someday, these documents will definitely speak. Therefore, I expect the Honorable Army Chief, the concerned police officers and the concerned judges to respect the law from their respective positions. Respect for the law and its proper implementation, commitment to justice and the rule of law. The protection of the constitution is the responsibility of all of us.

–Golam Hossain

Contact: Lawyer
October 31, 2025

Visited 30 times, 1 visit(s) today