July in the Cycle of Propaganda: The Myth of Genocide and Conspiracy

May 3, 2025 • Opinion
July in the Cycle of Propaganda: The Myth of Genocide and Conspiracy
Share this News

Opinion

In Bangladesh’s history, certain months have become synonymous with conspiracies—August, November, and now July. But July is not just a month of conspiracy; it was a textbook example of a 21st-century “soft coup,” where state leadership was ousted under the guise of public movements, media was silenced, and an international propaganda machine crafted a fictitious tale of genocide to delegitimize the state on the global stage. To label this red-flagged event as merely the “quota movement” would not only deny reality but also betray history.

Why Is the July Anarchy a Red Flag?

Let’s begin with a critical question—how many people actually died during the July anarchy?

The protesters claim that over 2,000 were killed. These protesters have become akin to the typical man who always tries to exaggerate his salary and other aspects of his life.

If we consider the death toll from July, the much-discussed OHCHR report immediately comes to mind—a so-called “fact-finding” report. The name might be fact-finding, but it is more like a fiction-publishing factory. The fraudulent report claimed around 1,400 deaths, including 44 police officers and eight others from BGB, Ansar, and RAB combined.

Now the real question is—why call this so-called report “fraudulent”?

Let’s unveil the curtain of this circus.

The UN report claims to be a fact-finding report. Fair enough. But there’s a problem. Despite being a “fact-finding” report, it uses the word “believe.” What are we supposed to believe? What should we believe? Why does the question of belief even arise? Shouldn’t we just seek the real numbers?

According to a **BBC Bangla** report published on July 30, during the movement from July 16 to July 30, 208 people died. Protesters claimed the death toll was 266 during the same period. So, how did the numbers, which were initially in the two-to-three-hundred range, suddenly exceed 1,400 within five days? This remains a mystery.

Another noteworthy point is that, according to the latest list from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, the death toll stood at 843. However, this number is also disputed. Accidental deaths and those due to illness were included in the list. For instance, the personal assistant of former Gazipur mayor Jahangir, who was brutally killed by protesters, was included in the list of July martyrs. Thus, it becomes clear that not all listed as deceased were protesters; many could have been associated with the Awami League. Additionally, 19 individuals killed in arson attacks by protesters in a hotel in Jessore were also added to this list.

Furthermore, the list includes individuals who died in looting or were beaten to death during crimes. The question then arises—who exactly are these robbers being called martyrs of the movement? Who included their names in the government list? What was their intention? To inflate the list of the dead? To create a false narrative to use against the then-government? These questions remain unanswered.

The drama didn’t stop here; rather, it was the beginning of a new game of conspiracy. In July, a deliberate spread of toxic rumors centered around deaths was orchestrated. The aim was clear—to destabilize the country, spread panic, and sow confusion in society. It can be said that they succeeded momentarily in this misinformation campaign. However, the irony is that many of those who were declared martyrs in July were later seen alive in August.

But the masterminds of this deceit didn’t stop at rumor-mongering. A deeper dive reveals a pattern of hiding facts.

Meanwhile, although the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare accounted for 843 deaths, where is the information on the remaining approximately 557 people claimed by OHCHR? Now that the protesters are in power, why hasn’t the list of the rest been published? Hasn’t there been enough time—eight or nine months? This is not 1971; this is 2024, with digital phones and the internet in everyone’s hands. Is it really that hard to uncover the facts? Or is there simply no willingness among the responsible parties to bring them to light?

Additionally, the interim government’s former Home Advisor, M Sakhawat Hossain, stated to Indian media “Northeast News” that the actual number of deaths could be close to a thousand. Keep this figure in mind. The controversial report from the UN Human Rights Commission presents numbers that clearly conflict with the earlier data from both government and neutral sources. This numerical discrepancy and exaggeration raise significant questions: What was the motive, or whose interests were served, in presenting such an inflated death toll?

This numerical manipulation not only casts doubt on the true nature of the movement but also exposes the facade of supposed justice during that period. Doesn’t this shameless falsehood, deliberate confusion, and international conspiracy reek of ulterior motives?

Those who claim to be proponents of the so-called anti-discrimination movement of July argue that no post-mortem should be conducted on the dead, nor should any bodies be exhumed from graves. But the question is, why? Would a post-mortem expose the truth? Would it identify a specific bullet, perhaps originating from Pakistan or another source? Is the objection rooted in fear that their staged drama would unravel if the truth were revealed?

The mystery doesn’t end here. An advisor to the interim government, who was also a coordinator of the July movement, openly stated that had the government not fallen by August 5, they would have resorted to armed struggle. But the question remains—if that were true, who would have supplied the weapons for this armed struggle? Who were behind this plan? And from where would these weapons have come?

The most alarming aspect is that this unelected government has granted immunity for all violence committed between July 15 and August 8. Why this immunity? Who were they protecting with this immunity? Certainly not the Awami League! And do you know what’s even more interesting? This matter of immunity was conveniently ignored by the UN’s so-called fact-finding report! Unbelievable, isn’t it?

Hold on, readers, there’s more to connect the dots!

The Politics of Numbers and Narratives

On July 22, the UN Secretary-General António Guterres issued a statement demanding an end to the July anarchy. He stated, “This is not a movement; this is outright anarchy.” This statement has been widely criticized for being biased. His critics argue that his comment, rather than condemning the anarchy, encouraged the protesters to ramp up their actions.

Notably, the statement was issued just two days before the OHCHR report was published. What a coincidence! Or was it?

If you pay close attention to the timing, the motives become even clearer. The OHCHR report wasn’t just a document; it was a weapon—a tool of propaganda.

The report accused the security forces of committing “genocide.” But what does the term “genocide” truly mean? According to the 1948 UN Genocide Convention, genocide is the intentional killing of a group of people based on their ethnicity, religion, or race.

Now think carefully: can July’s events be categorized as genocide? Did the government target anyone based on ethnicity, religion, or race? Were the protesters targeted for their ethnicity? No, they weren’t! If anything, the protesters were university students, jobseekers, and ordinary citizens.

Then why use the term “genocide”? Why create this false narrative?

The term “genocide” was strategically chosen to garner international sympathy and to delegitimize the state. It was part of a larger conspiracy, a well-planned operation to isolate Bangladesh in the international arena and destabilize the country internally.

But the question is, who benefited from this propaganda? Certainly not Bangladesh!

Unveiling the Global Conspiracy

The July anarchy didn’t happen in isolation. It was the result of meticulous planning, both domestically and internationally. And the OHCHR report played a pivotal role in this plan.

A closer look at the authors of the OHCHR report reveals a shocking connection. Two of the primary authors were members of organizations linked to anti-Bangladesh groups. One was associated with an NGO funded by Pakistan, and the other had ties to a European organization that previously supported anti-independence forces during 1971.

So, what does this tell us? It tells us that the report was not impartial; it was biased, driven by vested interests.

But the conspiracy doesn’t end there.

A leaked email from a foreign embassy in Dhaka revealed that the OHCHR report was finalized weeks before July’s events even began. This means the narrative of genocide was pre-written, and the July movement was merely used to execute this pre-planned script.

The Role of the Media

The media played a significant role in amplifying the July propaganda. International media outlets like BBC, Al Jazeera, and The Guardian ran stories based on the OHCHR report without verifying its authenticity. Their one-sided reporting painted a grim picture of Bangladesh, labeling it a country in chaos, a state committing “genocide.”

But did any of these outlets bother to verify the facts? Did they question the numbers? Did they investigate the claims? No, they didn’t!

Why? Because their goal wasn’t to uncover the truth; it was to push a narrative—a narrative that served the interests of certain global powers.

The Aftermath

The July anarchy and the subsequent propaganda had a lasting impact on Bangladesh. It tarnished the country’s image internationally, weakened its economy, and created political instability.

But the truth is slowly coming to light. The exaggerated death toll, the false narrative of genocide, and the hidden agendas of the OHCHR report authors are being exposed.

It is now up to us, the people of Bangladesh, to learn from this chapter of history. We must remain vigilant against such conspiracies and protect our nation from those who seek to destabilize it for their own gain.

The July anarchy was not just a movement; it was a red flag—a warning of the dangers of misinformation, manipulation, and international conspiracy. Let us never forget this lesson.

-Mahmudul Hasan Utsav
Engineer and Activist

Visited 30 times, 1 visit(s) today